November 15, 2014
The Quirk twins, about to turn 10, disagree about how to celebrate against a backdrop of magical mishaps.This year, Grandpa Quill's Quirkalicious Birthday Hunt will be the toughest yet. (Rules are helpfully spelled out: In the week leading to their birthday, there are five clues; four lead to small gifts and the last to the big one.) Facing a greater-than-expected challenge, Penelope and Molly disagree on how to proceed and who should call the shots. Additionally, for the first time ever, they are having a birthday party with friends. Molly wants her first birthday party to be perfect-and perfectly normal; Penelope's anxious about being the center of attention and keeping her splashy magic power (her thoughts manifest in reality) under wraps. This conflict of desires is heightened as Pen concludes that Molly's bossy, and Molly resents the sacrifices she makes to help Penelope control her magic. Additionally, the scavenger hunt's riddles challenge the girls, but nothing puzzles them more than the seemingly random small gifts. Will the twins reconcile their differences, prevent their birthday party from becoming a disaster and find their big gift? Of course, but the emotional roots of the disagreement will ring true for readers with siblings or close friends, grounding the story with a touch of reality amid the silly magic. This birthday-anxiety story is made fresh by both the twins' dynamics and the riddles. (illustrations not seen) (Fantasy. 8-11)
COPYRIGHT(2014) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.